The other Teach Yourself Bengali

William Radice’s Teach Yourself Bengali is, essentially, the Bengali text book, though it’s not of course overwhelmed with competition.

But there’s a lessor-known predecessor to Radice’s book, and an earlier entrant in the Teach Yourself series, and it’s this Teach Yourself Bengali, by DF Hudson, that I’m working my way through at the moment in preparation for our forthcoming trip to Kolkata.

I was given a copy by my father in law, though as a native Bengali speaker I was never sure why he’d have a first edition copy of the book, from 1965 no less, though it occurs to me now, for the first time, that it was probably bought for his (English) first wife.

His first marriage is not something I’ve ever spoken to him about – for all I know, he doesn’t know I know – so the book’s provenance is hardly something we’ve discussed.

But, back to DF Hudson, and he (she?) follows a somewhat traditional route to learning the language, beginning with the sounds you’re meant to make for the different letters.

I’ve always found this an off-putting way of learning a language. It’s part of the reason I’ve yet to make a start with Rupert Snell’s Teach Yourself Hindi and also why I found Radice’s book so refreshing in the way it eases you into the language without requiring you to endlessly practice pronunciation.

From there DF Hudson goes into a series of conversation drills that, somewhat unhelpfully, show the sentences in Bengali with the English written immediately afterwards. They also introduce tenses are a breakneck speed with little by way of explanation.

Nevertheless, it’s always nice to have a break from Radice’s book – which I’ve been relying on, off and on, for over seven years – and try another resource for learning Bengali, even if it’s a lesser one.

And DF Hudson does choose to end his Teach Yourself … with an intriguing set of Bengali proverbs, which is another plus point, even if it does make me wonder how many still are (or ever were) in common usage every time I leaf through the book.

4 responses to “The other Teach Yourself Bengali

  1. Good timing post for me. I’ve been wondering what to try to work through after TYB. When are you flying?

    • About a month, so there’s still time to catch with Bengali revision (though I’ve got to get a move on with finding a hotel for the Mumbai part of the trip).

  2. I’ve been tracing the female line back and got to great great grandmother who was from Mumbai, the da of a Portuguese trader. Mumbai is where her parents married in the Portuguese church and to find out who the mother was I have been advised I actually need to go there and try to view the certificate! Can you imagine – getting all the way there and then not being allowed to view it for some reason?!

  3. Pingback: Learning more Bengali numbers | A Tangle Of Wires

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s